Classic New York–style pizza, hearty subs, and comfort-food favorites in the Conejo Valley For a go-to pizza spot in the Conejo Valley, Tony’s New York Pizza in Newbury Park has been serving the community since 1986—known for authentic New York–style pies, generous toppings, and that perfect foldable slice locals love. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, feeding the family, or ordering for game night, Tony’s delivers the kind of classic, no-fuss comfort food that always hits the spot. Beyond pizza, the menu is packed with crowd-pleasers including sub sandwiches, pasta, salads, wings, and garlic bread, making it an easy win for groups with different cravings. Dine in, take out, or order online—either way, Tony’s is a longtime neighborhood favorite for a casual, satisfying meal in Newbury Park.